Approved Minutes of Oct-12-2011 SV-CC Meeting.

ATTENDEES

1111111111111111111111111111111111111
1111111111111111111000000000000000000
1000000000000000000111100000000000000
0998887665544332211210099988766554221
1213102202121311010012121010220212102
2841730285173066295807395184139628730
xxxxx-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx-xxxxxxxxxxxx*xx Charles Dawson (Cadence)
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx*xx Chuck Berking (Cadence)
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx-xx-xx-xxxx*xx Francoise Martinolle (Cadence)
------xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx-xxx-x-xxxxx*xx Abigail Moorhouse (Mentor)
xxxx--x-xxxxxx---x-x-x--x-xxxxxxxx*xx Michael Rohleder (Freescale)
xxxxxxxxxxx-xxxxxx-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx*xx Bassam Tabbara (Synopsys)
xxxxxxxxxxx-xxx-xxxx-xxxxxxx-xxx-x*-x Ghassan Khoory (Synopsys)
xxxxxxxxxxxxx-xxxxxxxxxxxxxx-xxxxx*x- Jim Vellenga (Cadence)
--xxxxxxxxx-xxx-xxxx-x-xx-xxxxxxxx*-- Amit Kohli (Cadence)
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx-xxxxxxxx-xxxxxx----- George Scott (Mentor)
-xx-xxxxxxx--------x----------------- Vitaly Yankelevich (Cadence)
xxxxxxx-xx------xx------------------- Arnab Saha (Mentor)
xxxxxxxxxx--------------------------- Arturo Salz (Synopsys)

---xx--------x-xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx-x--*xx Steve Dovich (Cadence)
------x------------------------------ Rohit Jain (Mentor) 
----------------------------x--x-x*xx Ying-Tsai Chang (Springsoft)
---------------------x------------*-- Doug Warmke (Mentor)
-------------------x----------------- Jay Lawrence (Cadence)
---------x--------------------------- Rob Slater (Freescale)

1. Reviewed Patent information

- Chas reviewed the patent information which can be found at http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt

2. Approval of agenda

Chuck/Michael. ACCEPTED

3. Review minutes from last meeting (Oct-12-2011)

Chuck/Bassam. ACCEPTED

4. Liaisons

• Francoise reported:
  • Champions email vote sent a couple of SV-EC items
  • Neil reported that the other committees are supposed to be completely done, except to resolve issues that were sent back by the Champions.
  • Jim asked if there were any VPI issues that were rejected. Francoise thought all of the issues were more or less editorial in nature.
• No other meetings to report.

5. Consent Agenda

6. Expedited Agenda Items

7. New business

• Review and assignment of Mantis Items from other committees needing VPI changes
  • Item 2987
    • Jim commented that there should be 2 things added:
      • Is something a soft constraint
      • The order matters, and that is not clear in VPI
    • Francoise thought we needed 4 things added:
      • A marker for soft
      • A marker for disable
      • A detail added to constraints diagram saying that they must be returned in lexical order relative to the scope
      • The effect of the constraint being disabled
    • Jim volunteered to put a proposal together
  • Item 3069
    • Local clocking statements
    • We had decided to ask them to try to put together a proposal for VPI, but we have not heard back to them
    • May not have made it through the champions yet
    • No one knew much about this one
    • Chas to ask the SV-AC committee again if they can put a proposal for VPI changes together
      • Chas may never have asked them... needs to review emails
    • Global clock was already in the LRM
  • Item 1356
    • This issue has to do with multiple inheritance
    • Arturo thought that there is no multipe inheritance. Should be called interface classes
    • Francoise thinks that it might not be a lot of work, Arturo and Jim thought it would be a good amount of effort
    • Cannot create an interface class type, can only extend existing classes. Is an abstract class
    • Did not get a volunteer to put together a proposal
    • Decided to ask the SV-EC to put a proposal together
  • Chas asked if the Champions considered if the proposal needed VPI access
    • Francoise said they did that in the past, but have not been doing it this time around
    • We currently do not have a list of all of the Items that we should be considering
    • Francoise thought we should ask the Champions to come up with a list
    • Create a Mantis Item to keep track of what they came up with
  • Item 3087
    • Bassam thought that we need to seperate the user view from the vendor view
    • Jim moved that defer this proposal to the next version of the LRM
    • Francoise thought we had a lot of momentum now, and it would be good if we continued rather than dropping this for the 1 year or so that we needed to finish this version of the LRM
    • Jim withdrew the motion
    • Ghassan liked the idea of trying to get a slimmed down version in.
      • Jim did not think we could do this in the time we have available.
    • Ghassan suggested that we ask the P1800 what our options are.
    • Decided to wait for direction from P1800.
• No other new business

8. Review SV-CC items with proposals:

• Item 3737
  • There was a comment made on the reflector after we started the email vote.
  • We did not get enough email votes for it to be binding.
  • Chuck will respin the proposal to address the left and right range issue

Motion to Adjourn. Chuck/Michael. Meeting ended at 1:22pm EST.

9. Review SV-CC items with proposals (Straw poll only):

10. Review old business:

11. Action items

Assigned to	Due date	Description	State	Notify
ChasDawson	Tue, 29 Jul 2008	Enter Mantis Items for Krzysztof Konopko's questions			edit

SV-CC Action Items List

12. Items for consideration at the next meeting (they already have proposals):

13. Next meeting

The next SV-CC meeting will be on Oct-26-2011.

The next P1800 meeting will be on Oct-27-2011.

-- ChasDawson - 2011-10-12