SvbcMinutes20160621 < P1800

P1800 Web>SystemVerilogBasicCommittee>SvbcMinutes20160621 (2016-07-19, MattMaidment) (raw view)EditAttach
SV-BC Meeting Minutes for June 21, 2016
| <span align="center">Attendee</span> | <span align="center">Company</span> | <span align="center">Mantis<br /> Perms</span> | <p align="center">Mar</p> <p align="center">15</p> | <p align="center">Mar</p> <p align="center">29</p> | <p align="center">Apr</p> <p align="center">12</p> | <p align="center">Apr</p> <p align="center">26</p> | <p align="center">May</p> <p align="center">10</p> | <p align="center">May</p> <p align="center">24</p> | <p align="center">June</p> <p align="center">21</p> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Shalom Bresticker</span> | <span align="center">Accellera</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Daniel Schostak</span> | <span align="center">ARM</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Steven Sharp</span> | <span align="center">Cadence</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Francoise Martinolle</span> | <span align="center">Cadence</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Mark Strickland</span> | <span align="center">Cisco</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Matt Maidment</span> | <span align="center">Intel</span> | <span align="center">M</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Brandon Tipp</span> | <span align="center">Intel</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Boon Chong Ang</span> | <span align="center">Intel</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Jonathan Bromley</span> | <span align="center">Oracle</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Neil Korpusik</span> | <span align="center">Oracle</span> | <span align="center">M</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Eric Coffin</span> | <span align="center">Mentor Graphics</span> | <span align="center">R</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">C Venkat Ramana Rao</span> | <span align="center">Mentor Graphics</span> | <span align="center">R</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Dave Rich</span> | <span align="center">Mentor Graphics</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Ray Ryan</span> | <span align="center">Mentor Graphics</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Sachin Pathak</span> | <span align="center">Mentor Graphics</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Dave Scott</span> | <span align="center">Real Intent</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Mark Hartoog</span> | <span align="center">Synopsys</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Brad Pierce</span> | <span align="center">Synopsys</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Arturo Salz</span> | <span align="center">Synopsys</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Justin Refice</span> | <span align="center">nVidia</span> | <span align="center">U</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center">X</span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
| <span align="center">Karen Pieper</span> | <span align="center">Accellera</span> | <span align="center">M</span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> | <span align="center"> </span> |
June 21, 2016 8am-10am PDT

Action Items

Open

Jan 19 Matt: Track version specific changes to LRM as AI and file if needed.

Apr 12 Matt: Add 484 and 305 to next email Vote

Apr 26 Matt: Add 343 to the next email ballot

Apr 26 Matt: Add 4528 to future email vote if 343 is approved

Apr 26 Jonathan: Update 2831 for future vote (WIP)

May 24 Francoise: Check on 5540, about issue raised by Jonathan

May 24 Mark: Send out options on 4927 that would clarify.

May 24 Francoise & Dave: Send feedback they got on 5531

Jun 21 Brad: Add new proposal for 1585

Jun 21 Brad: Update proposal for 2515 and send directly to Editor

Jun 21 Shalom: Update proposal for 3696

Jun 21 Brad: Update proposal for 5236 to standard format

Jun 21 Justin: Provide use case for 5540

Jun 21 Francoise and Dave: For 5531, Dave to send names of the responsible engineers to Francoise, and Francoise to get them to talk to her responsible engineers and extract a consensus recommendation.

Closed

Agenda
   * Review IEEE Patent Policy
<a href="http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt" target="_blank">http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt</a>

Directed attendees attention to the policy

Dave R. moves that we consider this read

Mark H. seconds
   * Collect Open Agenda Items
5540 and 5531
   * Approve May 24 Meeting Minutes
<a href="http://www.eda-twiki.org/cgi-bin/view.cgi/P1800/SvbcMinutes20160524" target="_top">http://www.eda-twiki.org/cgi-bin/view.cgi/P1800/SvbcMinutes20160524</a>

Dave R. moves to approve the minutes.

Justin seconds.

None opposed.

Jonathan and Neil abstain because were not present.

Motion passes.

   * Email Vote Review
Pass: 305, 343, 484, 3318, 4855, 5635

Discuss failing issues:

1585, 2515, 3696, 5236

   * Mantis 1585 [[https://accellera.mantishub.com/view.php?id=1585]]
   * Mantis 2515 [[https://accellera.mantishub.com/view.php?id=2515]]
   * Mantis 3696 [[https://accellera.mantishub.com/view.php?id=3696]]
   * Mantis 5236 [[https://accellera.mantishub.com/view.php?id=5236]]

1585

Anything but triggering single elements is an enhancement.

AI: Brad add new proposal

2515

              Merge in approved resolution of 343.

              AI: Brad to add updated proposal and send directly to Editor.

3696

              AI: Shalom to update proposal.

5236

              AI: Brad to update proposal with proper REPLACE/WITH format.

Open agenda items

5540

              Justin asks for status update.

              Jonathan says that all current tool implementations respect the enum constraint.

              Long discussion, including proposed enhancements, but which are not allowed in this PAR.

              AI: Justin to provide use case for 5540.

5531

              AI: For 5531 Dave to send names of the responsible engineers to Francoise, and Francoise to get them to talk to her responsible engineers and extract a consensus recommendation.

Stephen moves to adjourn.

-- %USERSIG{MattMaidment - 2016-07-19}%

---++ Comments

%COMMENT%
Topic revision: r1 - 2016-07-19 - 06:39:16 - MattMaidment
P1800