Date: Mon Jun 18 2012 - 21:36:52 PDT
I vote NO on the following items:
2840: The references to where the changes are to be made need to be fixed,
and noted in Shalom's vote.
3127: The proposal needs to be clarified as to whether "initial and always
procedures" should, or should not, use in the keyword font (Courier-bold).
4126: This is a request for a new language feature and should be postponed
for consideration in a future version of the standard.
4145: Shalom and Brad have noted a tangential error in the paragraph to be
modified, which is that programs cannot be targets.
4146: I did not see a proposal with specific changes to be made. The
e-mail discussion on this item during this ballot shows that it is beyond an
editorial change and needs a proposal.
I vote YES on all other items.
Stu
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Stuart Sutherland
Sutherland HDL, Inc.
22805 SW 92nd Place
Tualatin, OR 97062
stuart@sutherland-hdl.com
+1-503-692-0898
Training engineers to be Verilog and SystemVerilog and UVM wizards!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
From: owner-sv-xc@eda.org [mailto:owner-sv-xc@eda.org] On Behalf Of Rich,
Dave
Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2012 1:00 AM
To: sv-xc@eda.org
Subject: {Disarmed} Email Ballot due Monday June 18th
The following is a list of ballot items up for a one week e-mail vote due
June 18th. All members present at either the May 21st or June 11th meetings
are eligible to vote.
A "No" vote must include a recommended course of action to change your vote
to a "yes". That action could be a fix for the proposal, or a different
response to the item, ,i.e. that we leave it alone.
Any issue with at least one "no" vote will not pass and will go up for the
next e-mail vote, or will be discussed in the next meeting. Proposal owners
are encouraged to modify their proposal to address "no" votes as soon as
possible so that others may change their vote to a "yes"
EDA.org Mantis - SystemVerilog P1800
[SS] 4126
ID
Summary
0003525
2012 Ballot comment 41: property_statement should not be part of
property_expr
0004045
2012 Ballot comment 43: checker_declaration BNF does not allow nested
checker declaration
0003968
2012 Ballot comment 38: sequence_formal_type includes redundant 'event'
0003505
2012 Ballot comment 60: $ missing from param_expression
0004126
2012 Ballot comments 34, 35: allow for-loop initialization, step,
termination statements to be null
0004146
2012 Ballot comment 10: confusing definitions on p2
0004145
2012 Ballot comment 13. What does "variation" mean in 23.11
0003127
2012 Ballot comment 57: cbStartOfReset and cbEndOfReset callbacks are not
documented
0004120
2012 Ballot comments 21,27: mistake in 6.6.8 code example of generic
interconnect from 0003724
0004127
2012 Ballot comments 23, 48: difference between BNF and example whether
data_type appears before or after cover_point_identifier
0003710
2012 Ballot comment 32: Example may work wrong, negative values may be
generated while positive expected when using $random %
0003982
2012 Ballot comment 36: clocking_decl_assign allows expression or just
hierachical_identifier
0003065
2012 Ballot comment 59: Peculiar BNF for hierarchical_btf_identifier
0002840
2012 Ballot comment 28: Virtual interface datatype BNF incomplete
0004138
2012 Ballot comment 53: cross type compatibility inconsistency
0004129
2012 Ballot comment 50: Need to clarify ambiguous binding of matches
operator
0003298
2012 Ballot comment 24: Use of 'this' in a coverpoint expression
Dave Rich
Verification Technologist
Mentor Graphics Corporation
<http://www.twitter.com/dave_59> Description: Description: Twitter-32
<http://go.mentor.com/drich> Description: Description: Technorati-32
-- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by <http://www.mailscanner.info/> MailScanner, and is believed to be clean. -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.
