[sv-champions] Reminder - conference call May 14th, 8Am PST

                Toll Free Dial In Number: (866)839-8145
Int'l Access/Caller Paid Dial In Number: (215)446-3660
                             ACCESS CODE: 9301228

Hi Champions,

We are scheduled to meet tomorrow morning, Thursday May 14th, 8AM PST.
The agenda is to review the results of the email ballot, which ends at 7AM.
Hopefully everyone can send in their email ballot results a bit early so
that I can roll up the results before the conference call starts.

I am hoping that we will be able to accept proposals even if they aren't
perfect. The Working Group schedule doesn't have much slack in it and the
Technical Committees are official done with their work as of tomorrow.


Neil


-- 
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.


Hi Champions, 

This is a call for an email vote on the following mantis items. 
The email vote will run for 1 week, ending on Thursday May 14th, 7am (PST). 
We will also have a conference call the morning of May 14th, 8am (PST).
Any items that don't get approved in this email vote will be discussed in 
that meeting. There will be more mantis items from the sv-bc, sv-cc and the
sv-ec. It is my understanding that the sv-ac has completed its work already.

The following set of Mantis items are currently in the resolved state: 
I will send an updated list later today that has links for those that 
like to click on a link for each item being voted on. 

1.  2646     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Assumption in deferred assertion example should be made explicit
2.  2657     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Clarify notion of sequence
3.  2648     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Need an example of cyclic dependencies between sequences
4.  2649     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  sequence_actual_arg is used to represent the default argument
5.  2655     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Backward compatibility issue with the clocking specification
6.  2644     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #153 Wrong function named in table 36.9
7.  2630     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #168 Wrong format type named in Table 38-5
8.  2653     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Sequence match not shown in timing diagram
9.  2612     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  `true should have a backtick in a sequence example
10. 2660     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Add indices to expressions
11. 2478     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Clock flow subclause is not consistent with multiclocked 
	   property definition
12. 2661     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  "Syntax 16-19" is in blue.
13. 2659     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Backward compatibility issue with sequence property
14. 2541     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  syntax errors - missing parenthesis
15. 2516     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Another contradiction of existing text with 2398 needs to be fixed
16. 2496     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  non_port_program_item should contain assertion_item
17. 1775     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  cbAtEndOfSimTime not in header files
18. 2576     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Failed to remove reference to Reader API when deprecating Data 
	   Read API
19. 2621     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #155 vpiSize should return an error when applied 
	   on a vpiFunction returning string
20. 2623     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #157 vpiArrayType is labelled bool, should be int
21. 2626     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #162 In Table 38-3 in vpiScalarVal, vpi1 et al 
	   should be in bold
22. 2631     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #172 The usage of the the term PLI is confusing
23. 2637     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #146 Term PLI is confusing
24. 2628     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #164 In Arguments section, s_vpi_arrayvalue 
	   should be p_vpi_arrayvalue.
25. 2717     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Ballot comment #81 Clarification needed for the usage of 
	   severity tasks.
26. 2647     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Clarification about clock glitches in concurrent assertions
27. 2656     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Clarify difference of $global_clock handling in simulation and 
	   formal verification
28. 2658     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Default values for untyped formals
29. 2654     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Error in an example of throughout operator
30. 2642     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot comment #151 Need a similar rule for disabled 
	   SystemVerilog functions in section 9.6.2
31. 2643     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot comment #152 Section implies that a SystemVerilog 
	   function cannot be disabled
32. 2680     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot comment #32: Writing to an array with an invalid index
33. 2513     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  BNF needs fixes to allow checkers in packages
34. 2542     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Config declaration BNF bug
35. 2550     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  static variable initialization example has error
36. 2634     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot comment #20 Wording of paragraph implies evaluation
37. 2672     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot Comment #Macro expansion example incorrect in 22.5.1
38. 2683     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot comment #66: Example mislabelled "delay control" instead 
	   of "event control"
39. 2695     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot comment #169: BNF error in edge_sensitive_path_declaration
40. 2652     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Future value functions need clarification
41. 2562     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  rand qualifier for checker variables is not reflected in BNF
42. 2650     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-AC  Ambiguity in a sequence repetition [*0] definition
43. 2670     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot Comment #130: Module header description is missing the 
	   package import list in 23.2.1
44. 2675     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot Comment #103: Clarification of readmem warning
45. 2676     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Ballot comment #28: port connection warning
46. 1492     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-BC  Overriding default lifetime of subroutine formal arguments
47. 2625     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #161 There is a blue change bar at the bottom 
	       of the page.
48. 2622     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #156 Arrow missing in VPI Generate diagram
49. 2629     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-CC  Ballot comment #167 Function "vpi_get64" should be 
	   "vpi_get_long()"
50. 2627      Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___  
    SV-CC   Ballot comment #163 In Tables 38-3 and 38-5, for decimal 
	   characters, "0-9" should be in bold, for consistency.


The following list have been resolved by the SV-ec, but the mantis items
have not yet been moved to the resolved state. They will be placed into 
the resolved state today. 

51. 2632     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-cc id 16 approved email May 1 2009
52. 2633     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-cc id 17 approved email May 1 2009
53. 2705     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 35 approved email May 1 2009
54. 2700     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 36,39,40 approved email May 1 2009
55. 2682     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 42 approved email May 1 2009
56. 2430     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 43 approved email May 1 2009
57. 2701     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 44 approved, may 4 2009 meeting
58. 2430     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 45 approved email May 1 2009
59. 2706     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 46 approved email May 1 2009
60. 2713     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 47 approved, may 4 2009 meeting 
61. 2719     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 58 approved email May 1 2009
62. 2358     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 67 approved, may 4 2009 meeting [ with spelling correction]
63. 2596     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 80 approved email May 1 2009
64. 2710     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 106 approved email May 1 2009
65. 2711     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 107 approved may 4 2009, 6 Yes, 3Abstains, 3 No Votes
66. 2719     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 117 approved email May 1 2009
67. 2719     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 118 approved email May 1 2009
68. 2719     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 119 approved email May 1 2009
69. 2543     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id approved in may 4 2009 meeting
70. 2035     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 181 approved on may 4 2009 with 2 abstains
71. 2473     Yes ___ No ___ Abstain ___
    SV-ec id 184 approved email May 1 2009 (no action taken)


Neil