Hi Champions, Could everyone reply to me as to whether you agree with my proposal to run a 5-day email vote. I can't offiically limit the email vote to 5-days unless we all agree to do that ahead of time. >>My proposal: >>------------ >> >> - Neil calls for an email vote of those mantis items that the sv-ec and >> the sv-ac have updated by 11:59pm PST, Thursday Aug 23 >> - The email vote will be for a duration of 5 days, >> starting Friday morning (Aug 24) and ending Wednesday morning (Aug 29) Thanks, Neil Neil Korpusik wrote On 08/21/07 11:23,: > Hi Dave, > > Yes, that was my intent. I will not be adding any new mantis > items to the agenda. I think that Mehdi had a couple of additional > items on his list, but those will not be included in this email vote. > > > The SV-AC just wrapped up their bi-weekly conference call. They > are in the process of making the set of changes that were proposed > by the Champions. > > Neil > > > > Rich, Dave wrote On 08/21/07 10:42,: > >>Hi Neil, >> >>I suggest that we limit this to issues that were brought before the >>champions and sent back to the technical committees. >> >>Dave >> >> >> >> >>-----Original Message----- >>From: owner-sv-champions@server.eda.org >>[mailto:owner-sv-champions@server.eda.org] On Behalf Of Neil Korpusik >>Sent: Monday, August 20, 2007 4:35 PM >>To: sv-champions@server.eda.org >>Subject: [sv-champions] Email vote logistics >> >>SystemVerilog Champions, >> >>Attached is the email that I sent to the sv-ec this morning, >>which outlines the feedback from the Champions on mantis items >>that were approved by the sv-ec. >> >>Each of these was reviewed in the sv-ec bi-weekly conference call >>that was held this morning. Some of the changes requested have already >>been uploaded and several more are in the process of being updated. >>The sv-ec has requested that the Champions review the updated proposals >>by the use of email. >> >>I agreed to sent out a list of those mantis items that have been updated >>later this week. The editor has stated that from his perspective it is >>best for us to get as many mantis items as possible into draft 4 instead >>of waiting for the next draft. Several of the Champions were on the >>SV-EC >>conference call this morning. The SV-AC may also want to make a few >>updates as well. >> >>It isn't clear how the Working Group will >>react to a set of last minute changes, but I am willing to make the >>effort to see if we can get these approved by the Champions via email >>and >>then approved at the next Working Group meeting on Aug 30. >> >> >>My proposal: >>------------ >> >> - Neil calls for an email vote of those mantis items that the sv-ec and >> the sv-ac have updated by 11:59pm PST, Thursday Aug 23 >> - The email vote will be for a duration of 5 days, >> starting Friday morning (Aug 24) and ending Wednesday morning (Aug >>29) >> >>An email vote can be for a duration less than 7 days if it is agreed >>upon, ahead of time. I am aksing for your input as to whether you are >>in agreement with this proposal. If we need to have a full 7 days for >>the email vote, the committees will need to get their work done by >>tomorrow. >> >> >>Neil >> >> >> >> >>-------- Original Message -------- >>Subject: [sv-ec] Feedback from the Champions >>Date: Mon, 20 Aug 2007 09:53:45 -0700 >>From: Neil Korpusik <Neil.Korpusik@Sun.COM> >>Reply-To: Neil.Korpusik@Sun.COM >>To: SV_EC List <sv-ec@eda.org> >> >>Attached to this email is the feedback from the Champions on mantis >>items that >>were passed by the sv-ec. One mantis item was approved, after making 3 >>friendly amendments to it. All of the other items from the sv-ec were >>sent >>back to the sv-ec. Several of them were reviewed in detail by one or >>more of >>the Champions. The Champions decided to send the rest of them back to >>the >>sv-ec because of the large number of issues identified. The sv-ec needs >>to go >>through the feedback provided by the Champions and review those that had >>no specific feedback to ensure that they are ready for the Champions. >> >>The next Champions meeting is 2-weeks from this Wednesday (Sep 5th). If >>any of the sv-ec mantis items are to be reviewed in that meeting they >>need >>to be ready by this Thursday. >> >>1648 - the Champions would like the sv-ec to review this mantis item to >> see if it is applicable to covergroups. >> >>Neil >> >>- >> -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.Received on Wed Aug 22 16:54:27 2007
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Wed Aug 22 2007 - 16:54:28 PDT