SV-XC Committee meeting Monday May 21, 2012
Attendees
1. Dave Rich Mentor
2. Neil Korpusik Oracle
3. Dmitry Korchemny Intel
4. Shalom Bresticker Intel
5. Matt Maidment Intel
6. Stu Sutherland Editor
7. Francoise Martinolle Cadence
8. Surrendra Dudani Synopsys
9. Dana Fisman Synopsys
10. Ghassan Khoory Synopsys
11. Yatin Trivedi Synopsys
12. Brad Pierce Synopsys
13. Arturo Salz Synopsys
14. Ed Cerny Synopsys
1. Review IEEE patent policy
------------------------------------------------------
http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt
The chair brought everyone's attention to the patent policy.
2. Discussion
------------------------------------------------------
Dave - This is a technical meeting to go over the ballot comments.
- The spreadsheet of issues was posted to sv-xc reflector.
- The ballot review committee will be using the sv-xc
reflector.
Shalom - Noted the numbering is different in the different
spreadsheets.
Dave - This group will decide if the TC's need to meet to address
particular comments.
- The plan is to use the reflector to discuss issues.
- The TC's are free to meet on their own if they choose to.
- This is the only committee that will be officially voting.
Ghassan - The sv-cc has already met once.
Dave - was hoping that the entities that had an issue would
provide a
proposal. Proposals should be in the normal form for
any other mantis item.
Dave - The following process can be used to locate the ballot
comments
Go to the mantis web page
Click on "view issues"
Expand the "search" button (click on the +)
Use "target version" pulldown and select P1800-2012-D6.
Click on "Apply Filter"
That will show all of the ballot mantis items
38 items show up
- mantis 4121 is the master item for ballot comments
- some are for editorial issues (4061, 4122)
3. Items by Technical Committee
------------------------------------------------------
Editorial (2 mantis items - 21 ballot comments)
---------
Dave - 21 of the ballot comments are for the Editor
Stu - He has not reviewed these yet.
Dave - Will assume this set of 21 can be handled as editorial
for now.
Stu - The mantis status needs to be set to "Editor" for those
that
are ready for the Editor.
AI/Dave - move the editor items to the editor state
3127 - sv-cc
Stu - would like 3127 to go through the approval process.
- it is adding new text.
sv-cc items: (4 mantis items)
------------
Francoise - There were 5 items discussed in the sv-cc meeting last
week.
The mantis database has the following 4 assigned to the sv-cc.
2182
3127
4130
4132
sv-bc items: (4 mantis items)
------------
The spreadsheet has the following assigned to the sv-bc.
3065 (mantis shows it as sv-ec)
3505
4120 (mantis shows it is sv-dc)
4126
4138 (mantis item is correct, spreadsheet is wrong - should be
sv-ec)
4145
4146
AI/Dave - update the spreadsheet for those that aren't assigned properly.
The following assignments were made for the sv-bc items.
AI/Matt - 3065, 3505, 4120
AI/Brad - 4138, 4145, 4146
AI/Dave - update the spreadsheet (4138 goes to the sv-ec).
sv-ac items: (10 mantis items)
-----------
Dmitry would like to be responsible for assigning the svac items.
He is planning to do the assignment via email.
He doesn't plan to hold an sv-ac meeting.
3968 - was assigned to Brad
3525
3474
3032
3030
4012
3879 - a simple issue (Re: Shalom) - was assigned to Shalom.
4076 - 3 comments, that are related. A simple change.
was assigned to Anupam.
4045 - a bnf fix (it should be simple) - was assigned to Brad.
3940 - should be in svac (Dmitry)
AI/Dave - mantis is correct. He will go back and update the spreadsheet.
Dmitry - there were 3 items that weren't completed due to bandwidth.
- no proposals exist for these.
- these issues are important.
- They are not minor issues.
- 3474 - an enhancement
xxxx
xxxx
sv-ec items: (16 mantis items)
-----------
Dave has taken some of these already.
4141 - wasn't assigned.
Dave - wondering if the concern was people "without"
a c background.
4144 - was assigned to Dave
2840 - was assigned to Brad
2559 - was assigned to Dave
3394 - needs to go to svec.
In the past there was disagreement if changes were needed.
Assign to Steven Sharp?
3298 - was assigned to Dave
3659 - Shalom believes it needs discussion.
Dave - it has a proposal.
3710 - editorial? Dave thinks it is more than that.
was assigned to Dave
3982 - a change was missed in an update. (Shalom)
Shalom will look at it, to see if he can take it.
Will come back if he can't handle it.
4127 - a significant change
Scott Little posted a proposal for it.
It was on the reflector? (it isn't in mantis)
4128 - a simple change to the text
Dave wasn't sure what it meant by a "global constant".
Shalom - it is defined there.
Arturo - instance based constants and global constants.
They can both be part of the class.
Was assigned to Arturo.
4129 - has a proposal already
Shalom - a short discussion might be needed to ensure the
change is actually needed.
Dave - we can do this one over the reflector.
4131 - bnf change
Brad - it is an enhancement, not a bug.
wasn't assigned.
2867 - assigned to Dave
4. Process
Dave - for items that are ready to be voted on.
- change to immediate priority.
- can be done in the next meeting.
Dave - we are free to say that an item is beyond the scope of
our work
End of July - we need to be done.
Dave - the age of the issue doesn't always equate to the priority.
5. Next meetings - a change was made for the next meeting
June 14th, the next P1800 meeting.
- need to request the language for items we say no to.
June 4th - original date for next meeting of ballot review committee
- several people will be at DAC.
- this meeting has been cancelled.
June 11th - next meeting of the ballot review committee (new date)
- new date for the June 4th meeting, due to DAC conflicts on June 4th
10:43am adjourned.
-- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.Received on Tue May 22 11:31:28 2012
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Tue May 22 2012 - 11:31:29 PDT