[P1800] Seeking input on the importance of certain ballot comments

From: Neil Korpusik <Neil.Korpusik_at_.....>
Date: Sat May 23 2009 - 19:33:40 PDT
P1800 DRs,

Not all of the ballot comments have reached the resolved state. Some of the
ballot comments were marked as "must be satisfied". We are trying to gather
input on those which were marked this way but are not not yet resolved. We are
requesting that you help us gather this input from your member company.

Below is a summary of all of the ballot comments that were marked "must be
satisfied". 85 of the ballot comments were marked this way. Those that we
would like to get feedback on are those that fall into one of the following
categories. There are about 20 that fall into one of these categories.

    -- not resolved           -- no consensus yet
    -- resolved, no proposal  -- typically means no change will be made
    -- resolved, conflict     -- was a controversial item

I was unable to determine the mantis numbers for ballot comment #165, #166,
#22 and #128. So I couldn't provide any details on their status.



line   8  id  22  -- Editor mantis ??         ???
line  11  id 128  -- Editor mantis ??         ???

line  26  id  94  -- sv-ac  mantis 2655       resolved, no proposal
line  27  id  95  -- sv-ac  mantis 2659       resolved
line  30  id  97  -- sv-ac  mantis 2478       resolved
line  31  id  99  -- sv-ac  mantis 2541       resolved
line  32  id 100  -- sv-ac  mantis 2516       resolved
line  33  id 139  -- sv-ac  mantis 2496       resolved, no proposal

line  40  id  28  -- sv-bc  mantis 2676       resovled
line  42  id   2  -- sv-bc  mantis 2477       resolved
line  45  id  23  -- sv-bc  mantis 2550       resolved
line  49  id  33  -- sv-ec  mantis 2380   not resolved, no proposal
line  50  id  34  -- sv-ec  mantis 2380   not resolved, no proposal
line  51  id  56  -- sv-ec  mantis 2380   not resolved, no proposal
line  53  id  41  -- sv-ec  mantis 2681       resolved
line  56  id   3  -- sv-bc  mantis 2501       resolved
line  64  id  76  -- sv-bc  mantis 2691       resolved
line  69  id 123  -- sv-bc  mantis 2674       resolved
line  70  id   5  -- sv-bc  mantis 1651       resolved, no proposal, conflict
line  73  id 125  -- sv-bc  mantis 2739       resolved
line  74  id 126  -- sv-bc  mantis 2672       resolved
line  75  id 127  -- sv-bc  mantis 2671       resolved, no proposal
line  76  id 129  -- sv-bc  mantis 2610       resolved, no proposal
line  78  id   4  -- sv-bc  mantis 2593       resolved,              conflict
line  85  id 142  -- sv-bc  mantis 2513       resolved
line  86  id 143  -- sv-bc  mantis 2542       resolved
line  87  id 169  -- sv-bc  mantis 2695       resolved

line  91  id 144  -- sv-cc  mantis 2635       resolved
line  92  id 145  -- sv-cc  mantis 2636       resolved
line  93  id 146  -- sv-cc  mantis 2637       resolved
line  94  id 147  -- sv-cc  mantis 2638       resolved
line  95  id 148  -- sv-cc  mantis 2639       resolved
line  96  id 149  -- sv-cc  mantis 2640       resolved
line  97  id 150  -- sv-cc  mantis 2641       resolved
line  98  id 151  -- sv-bc  mantis 2642       resolved, no proposal
line  99  id 152  -- sv-bc  mantis 2643       resolved, no proposal
line 101  id 157  -- sv-cc  mantis 2623       resolved
line 102  id 158  -- sv-cc  mantis 2427       resolved
line 103  id 154  -- sv-cc  mantis 2645       resolved
line 104  id 155  -- sv-cc  mantis 2621       resolved
line 106  id 159  -- sv-cc  mantis 2582   not resolved  has proposal
line 107  id 156  -- sv-cc  mantis 2622       resolved, no proposal
line 111  id 164  -- sv-cc  mantis 2628       resolved
line 112  id 165  -- sv-cc  mantis ??         ???
line 113  id 166  -- sv-cc  mantis ??         ???
line 116  id 171  -- sv-cc  mantis 2588       resolved
line 118  id 172  -- sv-cc  mantis 2631       resolved
line 119  id 173  -- sv-cc  mantis 1775       resolved
line 120  id 174  -- sv-cc  mantis 1775       resolved
line 121  id 175  -- sv-cc  mantis 2572       resolved
line 122  id 176  -- sv-cc  mantis 2572       resolved
line 123  id 177  -- sv-cc  mantis 2576       resolved

line 128  id  20  -- sv-bc  mantis 2634       resolved
                      sv-cc
                      sv-ec
line 130  id  21  -- sv-ec  mantis 2715   not-resolved, no  proposal
line 132  id  30  -- sv-ec  mantis 2729       resolved
line 133  id  31  -- sv-ec  mantis 2729       resolved
line 135  id  36  -- sv-ec  mantis 2700       resolved
line 136  id  37  -- sv-ec  mantis 2700       resolved
line 137  id  38  -- sv-ec  mantis 2700       resolved
line 138  id  39  -- sv-ec  mantis 2700       resolved
line 139  id  40  -- sv-ec  mantis 2700       resolved
line 141  id  43  -- sv-ec  mantis 2430       resolved
line 142  id  44  -- sv-ec  mantis 2701       resolved
line 144  id  45  -- sv-ec  mantis 2430       resolved
line 149  id  49  -- sv-ec  mantis 2597       resolved
line 153  id  67  -- sv-ec  mantis 2358       resolved
line 159  id  58  -- sv-ec  mantis 2719       resolved
line 160  id  59  -- sv-ec  mantis 2575   not resolved, has proposal(email vote)
line 163  id  62  -- sv-ec  mantis 2606   not resolved, no  proposal
line 165  id  63  -- sv-ec  mantis 2607   not resolved, no  proposal
line 166  id  65  -- sv-ec  mantis 2723       resolved
line 170  id 101  -- sv-ec  mantis 2562       resolved
line 171  id 102  -- sv-ec  mantis 2718       resolved
line 176  id 106  -- sv-ec  mantis 2710       resolved
line 177  id 107  -- sv-ec  mantis 2711   not resolved, has proposal, conflict
line 178  id 108  -- sv-ec  mantis 2719       resolved
line 182  id 112  -- sv-ec  mantis 2719       resolved
line 183  id 113  -- sv-ec  mantis 2746   not resolved, has proposal(email vote)
line 185  id 115  -- sv-ec  mantis 2738   not resolved, has proposal, need pdf
line 186  id 116  -- sv-ec  mantis 2712       resolved
line 187  id 117  -- sv-ec  mantis 2719       resolved
line 188  id 118  -- sv-ec  mantis 2719       resolved
line 190  id 121  -- sv-ec  mantis 2750   not resolved, has proposal(email vote)
line 191  id 122  -- sv-ec  mantis 2543       resolved
line 192  id 120  -- sv-ec  mantis 2543       resolved


Neil

-- 
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.
Received on Sat May 23 19:34:42 2009

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Sat May 23 2009 - 19:34:49 PDT