RE: Call for nomination

Johnny,

Even if it has been discussed, we can amend the process if the participants
who are planning to attend these meetings, have previous experience which
tell them it may not work that well.
It would be a waste of time to be in a whole day meeting discussing erratas
if you are an expert of the assertions and you have to listen to all other
erratas discussed at length.
The way it could work without wasting any significant time from people
would be if there were sub- functional groups in which the erratas would be
discussed by the experts.
The erratas would be voted first in the technical sub-groups then brought
up to the errata
working group where the resolution was described, perhaps discussed
(typically less) and voted on. This last step was to bring up the
resolution to the whole working group in case it had implications on other
technical parts.

This is how it has been working in 1364 for 10 years and it worked very well.
Karen Pieper was the chair of the errata btf group and she performed a very
good
job. Perhaps she can advocate we follow the same structure and process.

Francoise
        '

At 03:48 PM 7/16/2004 +0300, Srouji, Johny wrote:

>I want one person to come to P1800 and present the collective Errata from
>all 4 sub-committees. He will bring the recommendations which will be
>ratified in the P1800 WG.
>
>I suggest that you talk to Victor Berman from Cadence regarding this as he
>was present in the meeting where we discussed this.
>
>
>
>Thanks,
>
>
>
>--- Johny.
>
>
>
>----------
>From: owner-ieee1800@eda.org [mailto:owner-ieee1800@eda.org] On Behalf Of
>Jay Lawrence
>Sent: Friday, July 16, 2004 3:14 PM
>To: ieee1800@eda.org
>Subject: RE: Call for nomination
>
>
>
>Johny,
>
>
>
>I personally find it difficult to nominate individuals for a position that
>does not as yet have a definition.
>
>
>
>What are the responsibilities of this position?
>
>
>
>As you know, within the SystemVerilog world in Accellera we really have 4
>erratta committees; design, testbench, assertions, and 'C' interfaces.
>
>
>
>Why aren't we preserving each of these 4 groups instead of having one
>erratta group which will in turn then be hierarchical?
>
>
>
>Jay
>
>
>
>
>
>===================================
>Jay Lawrence
>Senior Architect
>Functional Verification
>Cadence Design Systems, Inc.
>(978) 262-6294
>lawrence@cadence.com
>===================================
>
>
>
>----------
>From: owner-ieee1800@eda.org [mailto:owner-ieee1800@eda.org] On Behalf Of
>Srouji, Johny
>Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2004 3:42 PM
>To: ieee1800@eda.org
>Subject: FW: Call for nomination
>I am submitting this to the reflector. Please note the deadline is July 22nd.
>
>----------
>From: Srouji, Johny
>Sent: Thursday, July 08, 2004 7:52 PM
>To: Dennis Brophy; Vassilios.Gerousis@infineon.com; Oz.Levia@synopsys.com;
>mac@verisity.com; Hans Zander; Yaron Wolfsthal; vberman@cadence.com;
>steve_mills@hp.com; Peter Ashenden; Shrenik Mehta (shrenik.mehta@Sun.COM);
>Neil.Korpusik@Sun.COM; Clifford E. Cummings; steve_mills@hp.com;
>wolfgang.ecker@infineon.com
>Cc: Srouji, Johny; e.rashba@ieee.org; Peter Ashenden
>Subject: Call for nomination
>
>Dear Colleague:
>According to our F2F meeting minutes on July 1st, the following motion was
>made: Move Accellera SystemVerilog technical subcommittees to IEEE P1800
>Errata Technical Sub-Working Group . This motion was unanimously approved.
>
>This was followed by a motion to temporarily appoint Vassilios Gerousis as
>the chair of the Errata Technical Sub-Working Group. As a chair of the
>P1800 WG, I got the action item to initiate the process of a call for
>nominations for the permanent Errata Technical Sub-Working Group
>Chair. This motion was unanimously approved.
>
>Therefore, I am sending this note to initiate the call for nominations for
>the permanent Errata Technical Sub-Working Group Chair. Please send me
>your nominations within 14 days (by July the 22nd at the latest). Once
>nominations are done, I will initiate the voting process which will also
>last for 14 days.
>
>Please send me your nominations directly to my account.
>
>Thanks for your cooperation,
>
>--- Johny.
>
>
>
>
Received on Fri Jul 16 06:57:37 2004